It all starts with Robin's alarm clock going off at 8:00am and all the Titans run to the living room expecting presents since the past two years (soon to be three) they have gone without presents and then today to see they haven't gotten any presents again the Titans get suspicious. Then Robin says there was only one way they weren't getting presents... they were on the naughty list! So, taking a cue from Princess Morbucks in The Powerpuff Girls Christmas special, they go to the North Pole and sneak into Santa's workshop and while Raven and Starfire ask a gingerbread man where the naughty list and devour everything in his house. Beast Boy visits Santa's reindeer and ends up upsetting Rudolph by insulting him and he drives away in Santa's sleigh.