Cole had ordered him to kill an innocent named Greg Conroy. Originally, Cole told one of his top associates named Malick to do the job, however, Phoebe prevented this from happening and Cole vanquished him to keep his queen's actions secret from the Underworld. Despite Greg being in the protection of the Charmed Ones, Raim followed him around San Francisco and attempted to kill Greg in an alley with a Light Darts. Paige managed to push Greg out of the way, and before Raim had time to react, Paige orbed his athame to her and threw it into his chest, vanquishing him.