Catherine went ahead with her marriage to Morgan (1207-1208), only learning of her pregnancy afterwards. When Daphne announced her own engagement to Bramwell (1217) Catherine tried and failed to talk them both out of it, though she did reveal her pregnancy to Bramwell (1219). After Catherine participated in and "won" the lottery that would determine who spent a night in the cursed tower room, Morgan stopped her and took her place, emerging from the room intermittently possessed by the spirit of James Forsythe (1221-1223).