Jerry and Theresa’s anniversary plans are ruined over a fight about magic which prompts Alex to order Cupid from the World Wide Wiz Web. Cupid’s return gets delayed after Max accidentally breaks his bow and his arrow then strikes Justin which prompts him to fall for Harper. Justin then goes shows his love to Harper (by hugging, wearing the sweater she made him out of her own hair, impressions with French, deciding to join the scrapbook club) which at first she enjoys, but later she can't stand him and wants him to return to normal.