The story centers around Josette Collins and Angelique Collins. Josette seeks a judgement against Angelique for her crimes against love - if Josette wins her beauty will be restored, if she loses her soul will be forfeit to the dark master. Josette accuses Angelique of having come between her and her true love, Barnabas Collins. Angelique counters that Josette was happily married to Jeremiah Collins, and that her own love for Barnabas was greater than Josette's ever was.