As Paul searches for Alexander, he hears the sound of breathing coming from behind a curtain. Paul opens the curtain and sees a small girl. The girl asks "Why did you do it, daddy, why?" She runs off. Paul searches the house for the girl. He asks Julia if she saw the girl, but Julia says she didn't see anyone but David, who is playing hide-and-seek. While searching the drawing room, he notices the photo album and realizes the girl he saw was an 8-year-old version of Carolyn.