When Cleveland finds out about a plan to tear down the local drive-in theater in "The Blue And The Gray And The Brown", he attends a meeting at the Stoolbend Town Hall and appeals for them to save the drive-in. His efforts to preserve the town’s history is noticed by the Stoolbend Preservation Society and he is invited to attend a private dinner party at the home of the great-great-grandson of the town’s founding father, B. Emerson Plunkett V. The society uses Cleveland's enthusiasm to save a park and statue of the town father from being turned into a parking lot, only to find that he has been duped into protecting the legacy of a slaveholder by B. Emerson Plunkett V.