In the extended DVD cut of "Amish Guy", Peter retorts with a quote from Garfield about not being overweight but under tall. He then goes on an extended rant against Jim Davis and the book Garfield: His 9 Lives in which he proclaims that half of the stories are not funny and some of which are deeply disturbing such as "Primal Self", in which it is suggested that he kills his elderly owner. Peter offers to give Jim a pass because of the normal laughs given by the strip but notes that Garfield: His 9 Lives frightened him so bad that he needed to sleep with his mother Thelma Griffin, for a week.