Ichabod is buried in the cemetery on Olive's lot in Strangetown, and is the only Sim in that graveyard who died of old age. His grave is close to Olive's armchair where she used to sit in, if the players refer to Specter family's image in Strangetown story. It probably seems that Olive really liked Ichabod. He reappeared in Midnight Hollow. Unlike his The Sims 2 counterpart, he is an adult, has lighter skin and his sign is Pisces. He also died by electrocution rather than old age. Strangely, his tombstone indicates that he died of old age.