The "sheep and goats" judgment that was prophesied of in Matthew 25:31-46 took place in the Valley of Jehoshaphat in "Glorious Appearing", where Jesus rewarded "the sheep" who cared for "the least of His brethren" (speaking about Israel in the context of the Left Behind books) during the Tribulation with entrance into His kingdom, and sending "the goats" who didn't care for "the least of His brethren" into everlasting punishment.