In late 1998, Andy met Susan for lunch at Quake. At the same time, Prue was looking for him and spotted them at a table. When Susan introduced herself as Andy's wife, Prue stormed off angrily. Andy ran after her in an attempt to explain, though Prue moved a food trolley in front of him, causing him to trip. The following day, Andy waited for Prue at Buckland Auction House with flowers. He explained that Susan was his ex that admitted that he should have told her sooner. Prue accused him of keeping secrets, though Andy replied that he wasn't the only one.