Alex paints a mural for the school, but runs into complications once everybody starts requesting what they want painted on the wall. In order to make everybody happy, Alex uses the 'Eye of the Beholder' spell that makes the mural what everyone in the school loves. Alex, however, is unhappy, feeling that she compromised her own artistic interpretation. In the end, Justin uses Alex's original painting as the school's mural. (Running gag: People keep yelling "Knock it off" because of Theresa)