I feel something warm, even though I'm in the dark. My mind is swirling with worries about Duskwatcher. But one question pressed my mind more frequently than the others. But how? I was the prettiest she-cat in the Clan; of course Duskwatcher would want me. Unless... I open my eyes to hear whispers. Looking to the side, I see Duskwatcher curled up with a cat, a very familiar looking one. It's Shinecloud. My little sister. Duskwatcher opens his eyes and stares at me. I quickly pretend I'm still asleep. I have to bite my lip to keep the gasp from escaping my mouth. How could Duskwatcher betray me?