While at lunch, Shawn shows Cory a horror movie that he rented for them to watch that night. Alan and Amy typically do not allow such movies in their house, but they will be out for the night. Judy Horn, the Matthews' regular babysitter, is expected to be too preoccupied with her bad acne that she will not notice what the boys are doing. Earlier in the day, Eric failed his driver's license test, but he still agrees to go out on a double date with Jason and two very attractive girls. After the car gets towed, the adults must pay the man at the junkyard to get it back.