Charles Constantine, (born March 11, 1977 - December 27, 2018) also known as Constantine, was Fry's rival and Michelle's new boyfriend, whom she met on New Year's, 1999. Two hours later, while they were making out, Bender mistook him for Fry for a moment, before Michelle informed him of his blunder. Years later, he attended law school, while Michelle became a dog walker to help support them. At graduation, he left Michelle for someone else, so she froze herself and coincidentally met Fry in the future.