In 2001, Phoebe Halliwell received a premonition about Dr. Griffiths being brutally killed by a demon named Shax. When the Charmed Ones got the doctor to the Manor, Phoebe went up to the attic to find the vanquishing spell in the Book of Shadows. It was a trap because time was reset just before Shax's attack at the manor. However this time Phoebe was not there to help her sisters and both Prue and Dr. Griffiths were killed.