Spencer Walsh is Teddy's high school crush. He cheated on her with a girl named Skyler in "Girl Bites Dog". They broke up because of him cheating on her. In "Snow Show Part 1 and 2", he reveals he still has feelings for her. They kiss, but later she says she wants to be just friends. Later they start dating again. They got back together in "Can You Keep a Secret?" In "Bad Luck Teddy", everyone shows that they don't like their relationship because they think she is a jinx on him because the basketball team never won any games at all while he was dating her.