Julia returns to the Loomis House and Carolyn tells her she knows who murdered Angelique. Carolyn panics and refuses to reveal who she suspects murdered Angelique. She wants to go to her room to rest, but Julia won't let her. Carolyn tries to brush her off, saying it was only a dream, and dreams are rarely true. She runs off and Barnabas enters the Loomis House. Julia tells Barnabas of Carolyn's dream and wonders if William is perhaps the murderer. Barnabas decides to question William, but he gets upset with his accusations and denies killing Angelique. William leaves the house and Carolyn walks down the stairs. Barnabas confronts her about her dream and reminds her that it is bad to protect a murderer. He puts her in a trance and gets her to admit that Elizabeth killed Angelique.