Michelle was a friend of Paige and often got into trouble with her. She appeared to have the same rebellious attitude as Paige and was most likely also drinking and smoking with her. When Paige went back in time and returned to her teenage self, Michelle wrote her a note while they were in class, telling her she thought Donny, a guy in their class, was hot. Paige warned her that his future wasn't too bright, though Michelle didn't seem to care. Their conversation was then stopped by their teacher, Mr. Martin.