Cealey was one of the 16 contestants to make it through the right to stay. In the partner selection, she wanted to be partners with Alex, and despite Garret wanting her, she outright refused it. After the game Hangin' Around, Kelsey and Dakota put Alex and Cealey on the same team. She was excited, though was afraid of going home in the mission that followed. In Unwind, Cealey and Alex untied their rope first, and became the Green Team, the first official team on Endurance 5. After receiving her color, Cealey was proud she was on an official Endurance Team.