For Forgetting Sarah Marshall, Stoller directed puppet characters created by Jim Henson's Creature Shop. Stoller co-wrote the script for The Muppets, the 2011 Muppet movie, with Jason Segel. In March 2012, he signed to write the sequel. Stoller commented on the film in a 2008 interview: While early reports said Stoller would also direct the film, in January 2010, James Bobin was hired to direct the film.