In 2010, Clark abducted his family and forces him to kill Father Nathaniel Jensen, a local priest who was helping Abnormals. O'Farrell then implicated small time criminal Danny Stephano. However, the Sanctuary team soon found out about his deception, and laid a trap to get to O'Farrell, using Stephano as bait. However, when Bigfoot overwhelmed and confronted the policeman, he suddenly died.