A Muppet version of Gary appears in the film The Muppets during the song "Man or Muppet." The singing voice for the character was provided by Bill Barretta and the puppetry was done by Paul McGinnis. His speaking voice, resembling that of Johnny Fiama, can be heard in a blooper reel from the film. On the Blu-ray commentary, Jason Segel jokes that his Muppet looks like he and Jay Leno had a child.