After Cory and Shawn win a turkey and stuffing for donating the most food cans, they decide to split it by having their families celebrate Thanksgiving together. However, both Amy and Alan, and Chet and Virna Hunter are uncomfortable with the idea of mingling with another class. Alan and Chet almost immediately get into an argument about who is wine to serve at dinner, and Virna tries to calm them down. Meanwhile Cory returns from the car to see the dinner falling apart, and he and Shawn are in disarray as to how to fix it.