Lilly was one of the 16 contestants that made it through the Right to Stay, in which she's done exceptionally well and the only person overall to not fall. In the Partner Selection, she was the last girl to hang on, but eventually lost to Dakota. Via Cealey and Alex, Lilly was partnered with Aric, and he admired her physical strength in challenges. In the challenge where the last team would be eliminated, they were the 4th team to complete the task and choose a color, becoming the Yellow Team.