They hired a health inspector named Andrew Brown to find every trace of filth in The Pie Hole, and ended up having The Pie Hole temporarily closed. The health inspector demanded more money, or he would expose them for what they were doing, and got in a fight with Billy. Billy bit his finger off and swallowed it, and was then thrown into a vat of taffy by Andrew. During his autopsy, a finger is found in his stomach, but the print was erased by stomach acid.