In this second part of the season finale, Judgement Day, The Watcher tribunal believe Duncan has been killing Watchers with Joe Dawson's help. Jack Shapiro, the ranking European Watcher has gone mad in a bid to avenge for his son, who was actually murdered by the immortal, Jacob Galati. MacLeod tries to identify the real killer, while Methos treats Joe for gunshot wounds inflicted when Galati massacred Dawson's intended executioner and high ranking watcher witnesses.