Natalie first appeared in "Natalie", as an eager fan who encountered Caught on the street. She claimed to have the answer to 1AmTheHelp3r's coffin puzzle, and offered to come help Caught solve it. Despite her solution being incorrect, her suggestions helped Caught ultimately open the coffin. Though she was initially skeptical of Caught's claims that the Slender man was real, she relented in the face of overwhelming evidence at 925 Cranbrook Drive and has since had encounters of her own. She seems to have joined Caught in his hunt for the answers.