Kelsey was voted by the fans to be on the fifth season of Endurance, making her the 100th contestant on the show. She was one of four contestants to receive the free pass in order to skip the right to stay. In the partner selection, she wanted Dakota, and they become the second team on Endurance. They also receieved the Triangle of Immunity. They were the major force of the PROG alliance, and caused all the drama with the team switch. However, they were a strong team on E5; their only rivals being the Blue Team.